No original photo or video of this event is known.
The Baldoon Mystery, 1829–1831: A Haunting and a Silver Bullet
Last reviewed Next review
We review and update every article weekly. When the record changes, so does the article. How we review
On a farm near Wallaceburg in what is now Ontario, the McDonald family reported stones and bullets flying through windows, fires and phantom footsteps.
Verdict: A frontier haunting known only from later retellings, with no contemporary record to test.
Sources Neil T. McDonald, The Baldoon Mysteries (1871); Brian Dunning, Skeptoid #426 (5 Aug 2014); Wikipedia, 'Baldoon Mystery'
Baldoon was a Scottish settlement founded by Lord Selkirk in 1804 on marshy land near today’s Wallaceburg, in southwestern Ontario. In 1829, according to the story, the farm of John T. McDonald became the target of something unseen. Lead balls and stones came through the windows. Fires broke out. Furniture moved, and the sound of marching feet filled the house. Neighbors came to watch.
The witch and the goose
The family consulted a wise woman, who said a witch, perhaps a neighbor angry over a land dispute, was to blame. Following instructions, McDonald shot a black-headed goose with a silver bullet, breaking its wing. He then found an old woman nursing a broken arm, and the troubles stopped.
How we know it
The tale was published in 1871 by McDonald’s son Neil, with statements from people who said they had seen the events. Brian Dunning’s Skeptoid episode on the case points out how late the record is, and that the details match much older European witch lore. Wallaceburg keeps the story alive as part of its history.
Sources
- Brian Dunning, “The Baldoon Mystery,” Skeptoid #426 (2014): skeptoid.com
- Wikipedia, “Baldoon Mystery”: en.wikipedia.org
Verdict
Folklore A frontier haunting known only from later retellings, with no contemporary record to test.
Evidence ledger
Each claim in this file, the source it rests on, and how well it holds up: 1 corroborated · 1 disputed · 2 unverified. What the labels mean.
| Claim | Source | Type · date | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| John T. McDonald's family near Wallaceburg reported a haunting in 1829–31.Account published about 40 years later. | McDonald (1871); Wikipedia | secondary · 1871 | corroborated |
| Witnesses described stones, bullets and fires inside the house. | Affidavits collected in McDonald (1871) | primary record · 1871 | unverified |
| A silver bullet fired at a goose ended the haunting and wounded a witch. | Legend | secondary · 1871 | unverified |
| A human prankster or family conflict explains the events. | Dunning, Skeptoid #426 | secondary · 2014 | disputed |
Update log
-
We added this case file.
-
Weekly re-check of sources; no change to the record since filing. Next check November 23, 2026.
Discussion
Discuss this case on the on-site Community board — no GitHub account required. Prefer a private tip for the editorial team? Submit a Sighting.
House rules: Community guidelines.